Thiccstack
All cards, ranked
Green card art

American Express

Green

AF $150

What it is

The Green is an American Express card earning Membership Rewards points. It's mainly a sign-up-bonus play: earn the bonus, then keep or close. The forgotten entry-level MR card — broad 3x on travel and dining at a low fee, but a thin benefit stack means it lives or dies on the SUB for a churner.

Offer history

Current offer
40,000
$600 bonus · $555 year 1
Spend to earn
$3k
~$500/mo · 180d
All-time high
60,000
Sep ’25
Timing
33% below
vs all-time high
Value over time
Plot
$500$600$700$800$900$0$200$400$600LoungeBuddy $100 credit removed (service shutdown); Green left with only the $209 CLEAR credit. AF unchanged $150.AF $150 · benefits updatedOct ’21Aug ’23Sep ’25Jun ’26now
Year 1 (incl. perks)Bonus $Spend / mo (right)All-time highProduct refresh

Value is the welcome bonus at your valuations. The Year 1 total also counts recurring benefits and subtracts the annual fee. Spend / mo (the dashed line, right axis) is the monthly pace to clear the minimum spend in time — shown on every view so the spend stays in context.

OfferBonusValueYear 1ReturnDate
PUBLIC
40,000$3k · 180d$600$55520%Jun ’26
PUBLIC
ATH
60,000$3k · 180d$900$85530%Sep ’25
AF $150 · benefits updated · Jan 2025
PUBLIC
60,000$3k · 180d$900$85530%Aug ’23

What you get

No foreign transaction feesCharge card
  • CLEAR credit$209per year

    $209/yr CLEAR Plus — only meaningful recurring credit left after LoungeBuddy removed (Jan 2025).

Dollar figures are the benefit’s face value. What it’s worth to you — after realistic usage and your own point values — is in the receipt below.

The receipt

default values
SUB value+$600
40,000 MR × 1.50¢/pt
Ongoing benefits (yr 1)+$105
CLEAR credit
$209 × 50%
$105
Annual fee−$150
Year 1$555
Return on $3k MSR20%
Score
Year-1 value
+3.9
All-time high
+16.8
Return on spend
+16.0
Keeper signal
+0.0
Benefit ease
+2.5
Base score39.1

Your score sharpens once you sign in — we add eligibility, spend-fit, and 5/24.

Thiccscore39 / 100

Related cards

Green scores 39 here on default point values. See where it ranks against every card, scored for your points, spend, and eligibility.

Open the ranked table →